Doctor Who: The Ultimate Evil – Written by Wally K Daly, and read by Nicola Bryant (BBC Audio)

As Doctor Who fans contemplate their space-time navels at the beginning of the show’s latest on-screen hiatus, BBC Audio is offering up the chance to remember how the first such series break felt, with the release of the audio reading of The Ultimate Evil, by Wally K Daly. 

The Ultimate Evil was a script that was scheduled for the original iteration of Season 26, before then-Controller of BBC 1 Michael “Destroyer of Worlds” Grade put the show on pause. When it returned 18 months later, the original scripts for that season, including The Nightmare Fair and Mission To Magnus, were jettisoned into the void in favour of the (on reflection somewhat questionable) Trial of a Time Lord sequence.

At least the first three of those disappeared stories were novelised by their original writers, and both The Nightmare Fair and Mission To Magnus have had their own audio readings recorded in the last few years.

And now, The Ultimate Evil joins them, with a reading by Nicola Bryant, who played the Sixth Doctor’s companion, Peri. 

The Perils of Ultimate…ness

So… how is it?

Well, first thing’s first: Nicola Bryant continues her good work lifting stories from this particular phantom era above what’s on the original page. There are a lot of characters in The Ultimate Evil, and Bryant gives her tonsils a thorough workout running, jumping and standing still to bring them all to coherent, variegated life. So there’s that.

Beyond that…

Well, it’s important to keep in mind that Wally K Daly was an exceptional writer, beyond question, who could turn his hand to almost anything, from groundbreaking police drama Juliet Bravo, to medical accidentfest Casualty, to kids drama Byker Grove. He was even at one time the Chairman of the Writers’ Guild of Great Britain. Future Who showrunner Russell T Davies even namechecks Daly in his new book, The Queerest of Folk, for an episode of Juliet Bravo, which he describes as one of the best bits of television he’s ever seen – which is saying something for a televisual omnivore like Davies.

On the basis of the novelization of The Ultimate Evil though, one of the things that was beyond Daly’s grasp was the writing of an interesting, coherent Doctor Who adventure.

In fairness, he was his own worst enemy going in. There’s a truism in comedy that if you tell an audience in advance that you’re going to tell them a really funny joke, people will sit there with crossed arms, resisting any humour in the joke simply because you’ve told them it’s funny. They think they’re in control of any such judgment, so being told in advance will sour them.

Such is the case with any adventure that dares to say it’s anything “ultimate” – it makes the audience immediately bring to mind all the things that could be thought of as more ultimate than what you’re presenting. And in Doctor Who terms, there’s one “ultimate evil” – the Daleks – and then a whole host of “pretty bloomin’ ultimate too, thank you very much” also-rans to contend with. Yes, the Trial of a Time Lord season had The Ultimate Foe, but the storyline there did enough to justify the use of the U-word. And if we’re honest, the storyline of The Ultimate Evil… just… doesn’t.

The Claaaaaww…

Couple that with the always-unfortunate cover image of The Ultimate Evil’s antagonist, the “Dwarf Mordant”, and your back is likely to go immediately up, because it looks more or less like the evil cousin of the three-eyed doll-creatures lifted out of a grab-machine by “the claw” in the Toy Story movies. Unpleasant, certainly, but the Ultimate Evil?

Nnnno.

The story itself is intensely convoluted and rooted in a political philosophy that only vaguely works within the confines of science fiction, and if taken out of those confines would begin to smell a little racial. One planet with two main continents which were always at war until fifty years ago, when all contact between the two was banned – since when they’ve lived happily ever after in their magnificent segregation.

So far, so Thals and Kaleds on Skaro, but with a touch more obviousness in its racial separation message. 

Into this mix comes the Dwarf Mordant, sitting in a convenient asteroid in orbit of the planet, firing what for all intents and purposes is a “rage ray” periodically at the inhabitants of the country of “Tranquela”, to the point that when the ray hits, people will furiously kill one another if not chained sufficiently far apart.

The Doctor has old friends in Tranquela (naturally), but the method by which Daly brings him into the story is enormously long-winded (and would have been the bane of the props department if it had been broadcast) – there’s a kind of pre-Alexa Alexa in a ball-like toy, which recommends a holiday in Tranquela to the Doctor and Peri. The ball, needless to say, was given to the Doctor a long while ago by none other than the Dwarf Mordant.

Objection, Your Honour!

Still with us?

Good, because then things go seriously tedious for a fairly extended stretch. There’s a rage-induced accidental homicide, a trial, a nonsensical bit where young Tranquelans can travel about the place by “thought-bubble,” a visit to the Tranquelan armoury-cum-museum, and more than you could ever possibly want to know about the ruling hierarchies of Tranquela, and how someone in a subordinate house has acquired the ability to lie (which most of the country’s aristocrats have forgotten how to do!).

Still still with us?

Okay, then it’s time for a right royal overthrow, the deployment of hypno-guns, and the reveal that the “ultimate evil” of the rage-ray is actually part of a cunning plan to overthrow all stability on the planet and get the two continents to declare war again – at which point, Mordant will sign contracts with all and sundry to supply an ongoing and increasingly sophisticated range of weapons, to keep the war going until it’s no longer profitable. Or there’s nobody left who can sign contracts.

While we’re at it, there’s a trip for the Doctor to the other continent, which is in the grip of a religion created by a supercomputer, and people who think he’s both naked, and oddly stinky. Because, naturally.

Well, if nothing else, it would have eaten up another episode and ramped up the tension.

The Tension Collapses

All of which elevates the stakes reasonably well, presuming you can engage with the Tranquelan power-struggle (though that in itself is quite the ask). But then, Daly has the whole thing collapse in a handful of heartbeats once the Doctor and the Dwarf come face to kneecap. The Doctor essentially threatens to tell Head Office about what Mordant has been upto, and rather than rant or pull some ultimate evil out of his spacesuit, the wretched little homunculus just accepts defeat and naffs off to con another day – and the Doctor lets him.

Significantly less than an ultimate ending, there.

All of this makes for a story of shreds and patches – part Timelash, with its extraordinarily dull ruling elite, part The Keys of Marinus with its bafflingly extended legal case (seriously, there’s a whole trial in here, riffing on Sentence of Death from Marinus), and a heavy, but significantly less effective riff on Sil, Philip Martin’s sluglike disaster capitalist from Vengeance On Varos. 

That said, the Dwarf Mordant suffers from never having been delivered on screen, because Sil rose significantly above his origins in the hands of extraordinary performer Nabil Shaban. It’s possible that the Dwarf Mordant would have been similarly boosted by a stunning performance. But whether there would have been sufficient differentiation between two diminutive ultra-capitalists in the same season – in fact, probably in back-to-back stories – is a question we will never now have to answer.

Bryant To The Rescue?

Nicola Bryant, as mentioned, gives her all in terms of vocally distinguishing the variety of characters throughout The Ultimate Evil, but the pacing of the writing gives it a sense of hurry-up-and-stand-there-while-we-give-you-a-lecture-on-Tranquelan-history, which makes the story less engaging that it needs to be. 

So whereas Bryant’s reading saved the likes of Mission To Magnus from sinking beneath its own sexism and plotting oddness, in Daly’s story of rage-rays and the importance of non-war, not even her prodigious skills can really keep the listener engaged through all of its layers and inventions and elements that don’t feel like they do enough to warrant their place. Tony Fyler

If you like what we do and want to help us keep the lights on and the podcasting mics warm, we’d appreciate it if you bought us a cup of coffee

Be the first to comment on "Doctor Who: The Ultimate Evil – Written by Wally K Daly, and read by Nicola Bryant (BBC Audio)"

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.